摘要
法理是对法理学内容的高度凝练,其有用性直接决定法理学的地位。权利分析理论是法理的具体内容之一。在司法实践中,权利分析理论既可被用于澄清法律关系中原本模糊的法律概念,又可因其内含的权利—义务对应性原理被用于确定权利或义务是否存在。权利分析理论的司法实用性可基于对先例的分析得到证成。与此同时,权利分析理论在我国司法裁判中亦有其应用价值。从总体上看,否定权利分析理论在司法上有用的观点无法成立。我们可基于权利分析理论的司法实用性,借助整体和部分之间的关系,例证法理的有用性。
Fali is the highly condensed content of jurisprudence,so its value is an important thesis for jurisprudence.The theory of rights analysis is one of the concrete contents of legal theory.In judicial practice,the theory of rights analysis can not only clarify the original vague legal concepts in legal relations,but also determine the existence of the disputed rights or obligations based on the corresponding principles of rights and obligations.Thus,it can be justified that the theory of rights analysis is useful in judicial process based on the analysis of precedents.At the same time,the rights analysis theory also has its application value in China’s judicial judgments.Generally speaking,the view that the theory of rights analysis isn’t judicially useful cannot be established.Based on the juridical utility of the theory of rights analysis,the usefulness of Fali can be exemplified from the perspective of the relationship between the whole and the part.
出处
《法制与社会发展》
CSSCI
北大核心
2021年第5期28-46,共19页
Law and Social Development
基金
国家社会科学基金西部项目“类案同判机制研究”(20XFX001)的阶段性成果
关键词
法理
权利分析理论
法律关系
先例
例证
Fali
Theory of Rights Analysis
Legal Relations
Precedent
Examplification
