摘要
对辩论主义的根据,理论上存在本质说、手段说、防止意外打击说、程序保障说、多元说、法探索主体说、信赖真实协同确定说等观点,它们从不同的角度论证了实行辩论主义的必要性。由于现代民事诉讼法的价值理念包括实体价值和程序价值两个方面,并且民事诉讼在客观上乃民事诉讼法和民事实体法共同作用的“场”,因而辩论主义的确立和贯彻,有其实体根据和程序根据,是以此为基础的多元根据的必然要求。
With regard to the bases of the principle of adversary hearing, there are various viewpoints such as essence theory, means theory, theory of the prevention of unexpected surprise, procedural safeguard theory, pluralism theory, theory of the subject of finding law, theory of finding truth cooperatively, and so on. These theories demonstrate the necessity of carrying out principle of adversary hearing from different points of view. The article sets forth that there are substantive bases and procedural bases for the principle of adversary hearing because contemporary civil procedures have substantive values and procedural values, and civil litigation is actually the field where civil procedure law and civil law perform functions together.
出处
《法学研究》
CSSCI
北大核心
2005年第4期40-50,共11页
Chinese Journal of Law
