摘要
[目的/意义]揭示期刊声誉与高影响力论文的关联,探讨高影响力期刊作为学术评价指标的可行性,为期刊科学地理解与使用提供数据支撑。[方法/过程]采用描述性统计方法,通过定义期刊影响力区间,分析一组大样本高被引论文及刊载期刊在不同影响力区间的分布情况,并比较期刊高被引论文刊载量/率区间差异和高被引论文引用层级区间差异。[结果/结论]高被引论文主要分布在高影响力区间期刊上,但无论论文引用层级如何,仍约有2%~3%的高被引论文刊载在影响力居后的50%期刊上;而高被引论文期刊仅占期刊总量的53%,其分布也呈现高影响力区间聚集效应,且刊载量或刊载率越大,高被引论文期刊聚集程度越高。最后提出在不同的评价情境下,辩证使用高影响力期刊指标。
[Purpose/significance]The paper reveals the relationship between journal reputation and high-impact papers,explores the feasibility of high-impact journals as academic evaluation indicators,and provides data support for the scientific understanding and use of journals.[Method/process]With descriptive statistical methods,the distribution of high-cited papers and journals are analyzed by defining periodical influence rank,and the number/rate of high-cited papers published by journals,and the differences in the citation levels of papers are compared.[Result/conclusion]The result shows that high-cited papers are mainly distributed in high-impact journals,but regardless of the citation level of the paper,about 2~3%of high-cited papers are published in the lower 50%journals;higher cited journals account for only 53%of the total number of journals,and their distribution also shows a high-influence clustering effect,moreover,the greater the number of publications or publication rates,the higher the degree of aggregation of highly cited papers.Finally,the paper puts forward the idea in dialectical use of high-impact journal indicators in different evaluation situations.
作者
宗张建
Zong Zhangjian(Nanjing Medical University Library,Nanjing Jiangsu 211166)
出处
《情报探索》
2022年第1期48-55,共8页
Information Research
基金
江苏省高校哲学社会科学研究基金项目“‘四唯’治理环境下学术论文评价的多维视角研究”(项目编号:2020SJA0301)成果之一。
